Best club players at Junior. Intermediate. and senior.

Considering we will be locked in here is a toughie. It will take ages I think. Some great players over the years. I think we should keep it in the 2000 onwards. So get thinking. .

I suppose roli would have to be up there at senior level.

At intermediate it's a lot harder imo. I will have to think about it more. Maybe jack Robinson clougherinko.emmet Bolton or Barry lawlor eadestown until they went senior. Jacko McCormack sallins. Brian flood Eric Doherty rathangan. Niall Moran Seamus hannafin ballyteague

At junior maybe Sean Moriarty Colm fagan rathcoffey Tadhg fennin castlemitchell. Joe kavanagh Robertsown. Some of them would of been intermediate for a bit

If its club only then Roli at senior, Mikey Conway at Inter Spikes Byrne at Junior.

Could easily have Emmet at Inter and Tadhg at junior too

Senior - Eoghan O'Flaherty

Intermediate - Cian Bolton

Junior - Joe Kavanagh

Senior : Has to be Roli

Inter: Emmet Bolton

Junior : Colm Fagan

Senior: Roli but Ray Cahill would be a close 2nd, hugely influential for Sash in their 4 championship wins this decade.

Intermediate: Cian Bolton

Junior: Joe Kavanagh

All subjective bit for what it's worth for the first 6 or 7 years of Moorefields success Paddy Murray was the man and prob the most influential player in SFC at the time.
On his retirement Roli stepped up to the mantle and was the driver for Moores above all others. Sarsfields between the two Moores reigns I'd say Chalky and Cahill.
Two Flaherty brothers carried Carbury to 2 County finals and deserve honourable mention.

Wasnt Twomilehouse junior in 2010 when Peter Kelly got an all star ? Also Derek McCirmack with Ballykelly was key in that kildare team of that period. Super player

I really think there have been some excellent players at all levels in the last 20 years. I supposed we would need some criteria to make my question work better. Any suggestions?

As it is club player, only those who haven’t played a championship match for Kildare in the period in question?

topcat wrote:

As it is club player, only those who haven’t played a championship match for Kildare in the period in question?

Ok
Perfect

topcat wrote:

As it is club player, only those who haven’t played a championship match for Kildare in the period in question?

Still Roli

Junior - Tom Boc Kelly.

Anyone recognise anyone here...... A Typical GAA Junior B Line Up

Goalie - must have 'great goalmouth presence'.... which is secret code for being fat enough to have his own gravitational pull. Always in the 40-50 age bracket, this is a gent that will almost convince you that he played minor for the county in goal, even though the last time he got his knees dirty diving was at a ceili in 1965 when his version of the Hucklebuck went out of control, with numerous casualties.

Right corner back - the quiet man of the line-up he seems to escape the jokes in the dressing-room just because no-one has ever seen him angry and are afraid of hidden depths. Unmarried farmer with severe emotional baggage.Contact with a woman consists of the handshake at mass on a Sunday morning.

Full back - First started playing football some time in the Pleistocene Epoch. Nicknamed Sledge like "yer man outta U2". Will get a nose-bleed if he passes beyond his own 50 yard line. Utterly, utterly useless and yet is a great hit with the fans. Quite likes the smell of blood.

Left corner back - Has all the footballing skills of a piece of cheese and yet has been known to disappear up corner-forward's arses for days on end.An absolute cast-iron guarantee to be made mark the other team's young and absurdly fast superstar in the making.

Right half back - just out of minor, this boyo is sadly not going to get anywhere near the senior team... and yet hasn't missed a training session since early 1989. Selection is basically the manager's way of proving that he "doesn't give a damn who you are, if you're not down training we're not going to give you a game".

Centre back - disgruntled former senior player, tried to remove senior manager at agm and now has about as much chance of playing senior as he does of playing Hamlet in the Globe. Hasn't been junior training all year and is still absolutely guaranteed his spot on the team.

Left half back - county u-16 star, great white hope for the entire club.About 5 foot 4, he is still told to get under the kickouts and 'take the game to the opposition'... secret code for don't pass it to anyone unless your life is in serious danger.

midfielder - chronic alcoholic who last scored a point in the late 70s and yet reckons he is justified in having a go for a point from anywhere inside the opposition's half. Well-liked character because he always gets his round in at the post-match piss-up.

midfielder - the full back's older brother, who sports a rather strange looking bandage on his knee - probably hiding teeth marks or something.Prone to making strange guttural noises every time he strains himself. Eats five dinners a day and is a prime suspect for a coronary.

Right half forward - quietly-spoken business-man who hails from the village but is living in Dublin. Drives a flash motor. Lads who live in the pub in the town don't know what to make of him "but he was an awful annoying bollox in national school".

Centre forward - third of the set of brothers that includes the full back and midfielder. Is the target of all the brother's clearances... ALL of them. Probably the local A.I. man or something... by the way that's not A.I.in the Steven Spielberg meaning of the word.

Left half forward - utterly, utterly useless 25 year old who by some fluke of nature happens to be a deadly accurate free-taker. Tries to avoid open play altogether as he is far too important to the team to get injured. Is basically the team's only source of points.

Right corner forward - happily married man who hasn't played football since he was 12 but has suddenly decided to take up the game again. Natural talent (like his genitalia) completely and utterly over shadowed by his beer belly.Guaranteed to bag a goal or two and gain for himself some ridiculous nickname like "Schillaci" or something.

Full forward - hasn't scored since the end of the war but is captain of the team and an all-out nut case. The line commonly quoted to excuse his complete inability to find the target is "he's a good man to bust up the play." Doesn't feel satisfied unless his jersey is stained in blood... not his own. Will no doubt be marked by a similar figure playing for the opposition. Only at junior B will the full-forward and full-back play the game the exact same way, and could even switch positions with no effect on how the team plays whatsoever.

Left corner forward - the village thug, who invariably sports an ear ring and a seriously dodgy haircut. Will be involved with the referee within five minutes of the throw in. Plays the foreign game with the town five miles down the road and is hence viewed with suspicion by all and sundry. Has had a running battle with the aging club secretary who secretly fears for the virtue of his youngest daughter

Intermediate - surely stalwarts john dempsey-monasterevan.
Tom o loughlin ellistown

Gaa1928 wrote:

topcat wrote:

As it is club player, only those who haven’t played a championship match for Kildare in the period in question?

Still Roli

Roli played and started plenty of championship matches for Kildare during that timeframe?!?

John Dempsey a good shout at intermediate
Always thought Tommy o Neill was excellent. Did he ever start a champ match for the Lillies?
Still think Sean Moriarty for Robertsown a good shout bat junior.

If we want down would prob get a page of players at each level

topcat wrote:

Gaa1928 wrote:

topcat wrote:

As it is club player, only those who haven’t played a championship match for Kildare in the period in question?

Still Roli

Roli played and started plenty of championship matches for Kildare during that timeframe?!?

Apologies, I misunderstood the criteria.

Pádraig ' Podge' O'Flynn then.

Here's my selection. I've picked County players too.

Senior: Ronan Sweeney, Adam Tyrell, Eoghan O'Flaherty and Johnny Doyle

Intermediate: Mikey Conway, Peter Kelly, Daniel Courtney and Rob Kelly

Junior: Joe Kavanagh, Damien Leeson, Jason Acton and Colin O'Shea

Excluding Inter County players

Junior - Joe Kavanagh Robertstown, Niall Browne TMH, Austin Allen Straffan,
Inter - Wille Casey Eadestown, Jimmers Ballymore, Stretch Winders Sallins, Dempsey Monasterevin
Senior - Ray Cahill Sarsfields, JP Fogerty Larries, Dunne Athy

Best Referee - Liam Herbert or Mick Monahan

Only looking through the thread again after a break. As I said if you sat that you would probably get a list for each level that would qualify. Some great servants from many clubs. I really miss going to a few games at different levels and watching these good club players leading from the front