2022 Club Scene

All-Star Posts : 843 Join date : 2010-02-02

lomond wrote:: Any idea why Naas were awarded the u23 game against Sarsfields?

apparently some lad from sash was sent off during normal time and wanted to come back in extra time telling the ref it was a new game and got aggressive over it so the ref walked off

Subject: Re: 2022 Club Scene Wed Nov 16, 2022 9:09 pm

centreback wrote:

lomond wrote:: Any idea why Naas were awarded the u23 game against Sarsfields?

apparently some lad from sash was sent off during normal time and wanted to come back in extra time telling the ref it was a new game and got aggressive over it so the ref walked off

I know teams can go back to 15 aside in extra time if they have had a player sent off in normal time. I don't think they can use the player that was sent off but I am open to correction

Senior Posts : 162 Join date : 2011-11-30

Think if a team is reduced to 14 in normal time they can bring back on a player to make 15. Player that's sent off remains off though

Happened to us a few years ago, first year of the black card. Leagie final and had a player on a yellow and then got a black card so he was off. Extra time came and officials (ref and linesmen) said he was ok to come back in, our manager was also a ref and thought the same. Won the match in extra time, opposition appealed to CB and result was reversed at next county board meeting

All-Star Posts : 843 Join date : 2010-02-02

sorry i should have said it wasnt a player that was sent off it was a mentor so i heard.
Makes no difference though hes still not allowed back

All-Star Posts : 843 Join date : 2010-02-02

any update on the under 23s A? are sash out or whats going on?

Junior C Posts : 18 Join date : 2022-10-15

Anyone know why Sarsfields were thrown out of the competition due to the actions of a “senior official” who wasn’t sanctioned. The County Board seem to have made a very fast decision - posting the fixture for the Naas Clane game and then taking it down. Seems like young lads are being thrown under the bus. Is there a precedent for a team to be thrown out of the competition like this? Even in recent incidents where the referee has been actually assaulted the team has continued in the competition with the assailant(s) receiving bans

Intermediate Posts : 98 Join date : 2021-09-27

I see Tommy Callaghan in todays Leinster leader has really put it up to Naas u23 to offer Sarsfields a replay .What does anyone think of that ?

All-Star Posts : 843 Join date : 2010-02-02

DannyBoy wrote:: Anyone know why Sarsfields were thrown out of the competition due to the actions of a “senior official” who wasn’t sanctioned. The County Board seem to have made a very fast decision - posting the fixture for the Naas Clane game and then taking it down. Seems like young lads are being thrown under the bus. Is there a precedent for a team to be thrown out of the competition like this? Even in recent incidents where the referee has been actually assaulted the team has continued in the competition with the assailant(s) receiving bans

Good point but what are sarsfields doing about the behaviour of the person that was sent off? from what im hearing they`re defending his actions but he must have done something to seriously piss the ref off and thats not acceptable referees need to be protected from any form of abuse and it seems to be an accepted culture in the gaa that you can talk to refs in any aggressive form you like when you feel a decision has being giving wrongly against you.

Senior Posts : 188 Join date : 2010-07-15

fatherted

Think if a team is reduced to 14 in normal time they can bring back on a player to make 15. Player that's sent off remains off though

Happened to us a few years ago, first year of the black card. Leagie final and had a player on a yellow and then got a black card so he was off. Extra time came and officials (ref and linesmen) said he was ok to come back in, our manager was also a ref and thought the same. Won the match in extra time, opposition appealed to CB and result was reversed at next county board meeting

Game awarded only after ye refused a replay

Intermediate Posts : 96 Join date : 2022-06-07

Any truth in the d mull hall transfer ?

Intermediate Posts : 76 Join date : 2020-11-16

To Barrowhouse?

Intermediate Posts : 96 Join date : 2022-06-07

Castlemitchell

Senior Posts : 192 Join date : 2022-05-18

ndog wrote:

Leead64 wrote:: Murder at hawkfield tonight during the minor games. Gardai at the scene. Whats going on in the game altogether.

What happened?

cocaine

» 2023 Club Scene
» 2024 Club Scene
» Club Scene 2019
» Leinster championship 2022
» O'Byrne Cup 2022