2023 Club Scene

All-Star Posts : 843 Join date : 2010-02-02

sash best hope is for athy to beat naas which could happen with naas already through

Junior A Posts : 21 Join date : 2022-06-11

Anyone have any predictions for group b? Is there a genuine belief that the sash could go out? Or will they get it done against maynooth. Can’t see athy beating naas don’t think naas have the mindset to look forward to another game they will want to win every game possible

All-Star Posts : 1120 Join date : 2011-11-25

Yeah Naas should beat Athy, they wont want to lose momentum and will want Sash out ,Sash have to beat Maynooth by 6 to stay in it if Naas win. Wont be easy but have feeling they will scrape thru.

All-Star Posts : 642 Join date : 2010-01-31

Its very possible (even likely) that sarsfields go out.

If they beat Maynooth by 7+ they are through . Other than that, its difficult to see them getting through.

Barry Coffey is back which will be a big help but its a big ask to turnover maynooth by so much.

Serious group of death !! Whoever exits will feel very hard done by compared to the teams coming through group a or even the losers group

Group A is fairly straight forward, shoot out between Celbridge and Clane for top spot this week end. Both are through. Then a shoot out beween Cloghs and Carbury for third place and qualification

I think what lilysavage is most likely. Naas will want sash out and will want to put manners on athys championship notions by winning. That means mostly likely 3 teams on 2 points if sash win.. Then it comes down to points diff between those 3 teams only (not naas) ... Sash need to beat maynooth by 6 in that case i think.... Its all very close to call but its got ppl talking which is great !

All-Star Posts : 642 Join date : 2010-01-31

Prediction:

Prelim Quarter Final

Cloghs
Moores
Athy
Eadestown

Quarter Final

Naas
Maynooth
Celbridge
Clane
Raheens
JTB

Relegation

Larries v Ballyteague

Anyone else care to have a guess??

Intercounty Posts : 314 Join date : 2023-02-11

I did a few permutations sheets for the SFC and IFC that I published on my Twitter if anyone is on there and needs a clearer picture on it. Tried to upload here but keep making a balls of it.

Senior Posts : 238 Join date : 2016-07-28

really_unofficial_kildare wrote:: I did a few permutations sheets for the SFC and IFC that I published on my Twitter if anyone is on there and needs a clearer picture on it. Tried to upload here but keep making a balls of it.

They are done very well. Keep up the great work

Subject: Re: 2023 Club Scene Thu Sep 07, 2023 7:41 pm

really_unofficial_kildare wrote:: I did a few permutations sheets for the SFC and IFC that I published on my Twitter if anyone is on there and needs a clearer picture on it. Tried to upload here but keep making a balls of it.

The work you do regarding the club scene is unbelievable. Our county PRO want to take a leaf out of your book. Keep up the great work

All-Star Posts : 1713 Join date : 2013-07-22

So am I right in thinking that the current score difference in group B, leaving the Naas matches out, is as follows:

Maynooth = 6
Athy = 0
Sarsfieldss = -6

If Sarsfields win by 6 points and Athy lose what's the next criteria for deciding finishing places.

Personally I think Sarsfields and Athy will qualify in 2nd & 3rd place.

All-Star Posts : 642 Join date : 2010-01-31

Its scoring difference between the three teams involved only followed by points scored i think versus the teams involved.

So in your case...

All three teams would be on nil in scoring difference versus each other.

Points scored would be

Athy 31 points scored
Sarsfields 15 + xx
Maynooth 16 + xx

So it depends on the final result in the Sarsfields maynooth game. So lets assume It finished Sarsfiedls 2.13 Maynooth 13 points

Then it would be
Athy 31
Sarsfields 15 + 19 = 34
Maynooth 16 + 13 = 29.

Sarsfields and Athy would progress.

I guess the long and short of it is if Athy lose, Sarsfields win by 6 its very unlikely Maynooth will score enough to lose by 6 and still get over Athys total of 31..

Lot of permutations but think that is it

All-Star Posts : 642 Join date : 2010-01-31

I think the "only" way Athy can be eliminated is if Maynooth lose by 6 but rack up 16+ points in doing so...

So Sarsfields 2.16 Maynooth 16 points (or 2.17 v 17 etc) would see Athy eliminated.

If Sarsfields win by 7 + its Sarsfields and Athy
If Sarsfields win by 1+ to 5 its Athy and Maynooth

Athy would want to be seriously unlucky to miss out

All-Star Posts : 1120 Join date : 2011-11-25

Also, a 1-5 point win would do Sash if Athy get a win or draw.

All-Star Posts : 642 Join date : 2010-01-31

Yes a draw or win for Athy v Naas means thats any win for sarsfields v maynooth will put them through

Senior Posts : 198 Join date : 2017-12-14

Was up in the Park again last night and caught Nurney V Straffan, Impressed for a second game in a row with Cathal Hagney from Nurney. Strong, Athletic and can kick a score, Glen could do worse than bring him in

Intermediate Posts : 96 Join date : 2022-06-07

Onechance wrote:: Was up in the Park again last night and caught Nurney V Straffan, Impressed for a second game in a row with Cathal Hagney from Nurney. Strong, Athletic and can kick a score, Glen could do worse than bring him in

Hahahaha

Junior A Posts : 21 Join date : 2022-06-11

Has anyone watched maynooth this year? Seem to have done well against naas and obviously beating athy from a division 2 is a big achievement. Will sarsfields win on Sunday or could we see them out in the group stages? Not sure where they are in terms of the odds would be interesting to know

Intermediate Posts : 98 Join date : 2021-09-27

Sarsfields are 10/1 with pp,very good value in my opinion.Unlucky in both games so far .They were all over Naas in the first half only to concede a soft goal at the end of the first half and conceded another soft goal early in the second half .
They had 5 wides in a row including a simple 21m free .On another day Sarsfield could have won ..Sarsfields could be very good.Worth a tenner ?

Intermediate Posts : 98 Join date : 2021-09-27

Whereas Maynooth are 33/1 to win the championship.

Senior Posts : 238 Join date : 2016-07-28

gunnerman wrote:: Sarsfields are 10/1 with pp,very good value in my opinion.Unlucky in both games so far .They were all over Naas in the first half only to concede a soft goal at the end of the first half and conceded another soft goal early in the second half .
They had 5 wides in a row including a simple 21m free .On another day Sarsfield could have won ..Sarsfields could be very good.Worth a tenner ?

You obviously don't like money!

Intercounty Posts : 377 Join date : 2022-01-09

Castlemitchell received a walk over from Ardclough. Ardclough only had 10 players.

Senior Posts : 171 Join date : 2021-09-01

gunnerman wrote:: Sarsfields are 10/1 with pp,very good value in my opinion.Unlucky in both games so far .They were all over Naas in the first half only to concede a soft goal at the end of the first half and conceded another soft goal early in the second half .
They had 5 wides in a row including a simple 21m free .On another day Sarsfield could have won ..Sarsfields could be very good.Worth a tenner ?

They have absolutely no chance of winning the championship.

Senior Posts : 171 Join date : 2021-09-01

Leixlip out .alot of people fancied them. Tough group that.

Senior Posts : 121 Join date : 2016-04-01 Age : 123

FlourBag_1 wrote:: Castlemitchell received a walk over from Ardclough. Ardclough only had 10 players.

Seems very unfair on Rheban who lost out to Ardclough by a point earlier in the week. They lost out on a tie v Castlemitchell based on being beating by a team who did'nt turn up for the next knockout round. Surely there has to be a sanction or some implications for such carry on.
When is the CB or CCC actually going to tackle this issue with Ardclough. Making a mockery of the both the league and championship competitions with this carry on, year in , year out.

Intermediate Posts : 96 Join date : 2022-06-07

Hurlerbehindtheditch wrote:

FlourBag_1 wrote:: Castlemitchell received a walk over from Ardclough. Ardclough only had 10 players.

Seems very unfair on Rheban who lost out to Ardclough by a point earlier in the week. They lost out on a tie v Castlemitchell based on being beating by a team who did'nt turn up for the next knockout round. Surely there has to be a sanction or some implications for such carry on.
When is the CB or CCC actually going to tackle this issue with Ardclough. Making a mockery of the both the league and championship competitions with this carry on, year in , year out.

Absolute disgrace from ardclough once again

Senior Posts : 154 Join date : 2018-05-22

Clubman wrote:: Leixlip out .alot of people fancied them. Tough group that.

Leixlip didn’t win a match in the group so they can’t really complain but it shows how silly the system is when their prize for winning their preliminary match was a group with Allenwood, Castledermot and Sallins.

Had they lost, they could have been in Group D with Ballymore, Kilcullen and Suncroft. I know which group I’d rather be in.

» Minors 2023
» Club Scene 2019
» 2024 Club Scene
» 2022 Club Scene
» Under 20s 2023